John McCarthy

College and amateur

McCarthy played four years of college soccer at La Salle University between 2010 and 2013, Where he holds numerous career records, including most games played (74), saves (468), and shutouts (28). He was awarded Atlantic 10 All-Conference Second Team in 2011 and 2012, as well as Atlantic 10 All-Conference First Team in 2013. While at college, McCarthy also appeared for USL PDL clubs Ocean City Nor'easters in 2011 and 2012, and Reading United AC in 2013.

Professional

Rochester Rhinos

McCarthy signed his first professional deal with USL Pro club Rochester Rhinos on February 27, 2014. After the 2014 season, McCarthy was named the Rhinos' Rookie of the Year as he led the league with 0.72 goals against average. McCarthy was named USL PRO Goalkeeper of the Year and USL PRO Rookie of the Year for his notable 2014 season performances.

Philadelphia Union

In 2015, McCarthy signed with his hometown club, Philadelphia Union. Originally signed as a third goalkeeper behind first round draft pick, Andre Blake, and designated player, Rais M'Bohli, McCarthy was given a starting role as a result of injury and poor form, respectively. He made his MLS debut as the starter for the Union on April 11, 2015, versus New York City FC. McCarthy was heralded for his performance which resulted in his first win in the topflight as well as the Union's first win of 2015 season. McCarthy started 8 league matches during the 2015 season, posting…

As of match played October 19, 2025