Tyler McCamey

After the 2020 season was cancelled due to the COVID-19 pandemic, McCamey was mostly a backup in her freshman season in 2021, making three starts for the Princeton Tigers. She shared goalkeeping duties as a sophomore, playing 70% of the minutes, with 2 solo shutouts (8 total) in 15 games. She started all 19 games in her junior year in 2023, keeping 6 clean sheets (7 total) including in both games at the NCAA tournament, losing in the second round on penalties. She co-captained Princeton with Heather MacNab in her senior year in 2024, leading the team to the Ivy League regular-season and tournament titles. She posted 8 solo clean sheets in 17 games, with 0.65 goals against average, was named first-team All-Ivy.

Gotham FC and Kansas City Current

While completing her undergraduate studies in the spring of 2025, McCamey began her professional career unexpectedly early when the National Women's Soccer League (NWSL)'s Gotham FC reached out in April: Ann-Katrin Berger needed a backup after injuries to Shelby Hogan and Ryan Campbell. On April 17, Gotham FC signed McCamey and recently retired Michelle Betos, the club's assistant goalkeeping coach, to short-term injury replacement contracts. McCamey was on the bench for two league games and two games at the CONCACAF W Champions Cup (which Gotham won) before departing the club in June. In July, she trained with the North Carolina Courage for three weeks. On September 5, 2025, the Kansas City Current announced that they had signed McCamey for the remainder of the season after an injury to third-string rookie Clare Gagne. She made no competitive appearances as the Current won the NWSL Shield, but she impressed at the World Sevens Football invitational tournament in December, saving two penalty kicks at the seven-a-side competition.

Dallas Trinity

On January 20, 2026, the Dallas Trinity announced that McCamey had signed with the club for the spring portion of the USL Super League season, reuniting with former North Carolina Courage coach Nathan Thackeray. She won the starting job over Samantha Estrada and made her professional debut later that month in a 1–1 draw with Brooklyn FC. The following game, she kept almost 80…

Growing up in Atlanta, McCamey played club soccer for Tophat, serving as team captain, in both the DA and the ECNL. She committed to play college soccer at Princeton University during her junior year at the Westminster Schools.

Princeton Tigers

Ivy League: 2024 Ivy League tournament: 2024 Gotham FC

CONCACAF W Champions Cup: 2024–25 Kansas City Current

NWSL Shield: 2025 Individual

First-team All-Ivy League: 2024